Skip to content
Re-grill · 20 Nov · Round 1 of 5

BidKit landing page review

87
Well done
was 87

Higher than 62 of the 63 other launches on the public record (98%)

“The page is highly effective, but hides its strongest proof and attaches a 'no updates' poison pill to the entry tier.” 

What we read, 20 Nov at 20:25, at laptop and phone width.

Fix this first

Offer a limited update window (e.g., 6 months) for the Starter tier

Costly · minutes · up to +5.5. From your page’s line “No future updates” (copy test O2).

Then

  1. 2Place the Outbid.lol $90k result in the ‘Why this exists’ sectionnot scored
  2. 3Remove ‘untouched’ and guarantee the kit’s functionalitynot scored
Fix 1:8792Well done· 2 and 3 are outside the score

The numbers

This page, in numbers.

Its four scores against the public record, and its public grills over time.

Its four axes

bidkit.lolthe median launch on the public record
100
median 81
81
median 64
100
median 77
56
median 39
Audience563 of 4 tests pass

It names directory, newsletter and community owners, but the problem it solves only appears below the first screen.

  • passed:A1Named
  • passed:A2Their words
  • missed:A3Pain before product
  • passed:A4The payer

A3, missed: The problem is not stated until the ‘Why this exists’ section below the fold.

Choose an axis to read it.

Where 87 sits

62 of 63other launches score lower

0s10s20s30s40s50s60s70s80s90smedian 66

The public record, 22 Nov: each launch counted once, by its latest public grill.

Its public grills

2 publicsince 27 Sept. This one, 87, ties the best.

050100878727 Sept20 Novv0.13

Under the dates, the rubric each was graded on; today’s is v0.14. Hollow dots: an older rubric, so not comparable one to one. Private grills are left out: only the owner sees them.

In their own words

What people looking for this kind of product write, quoted as they wrote it.

  • “Is it considered appropriate (or useful) to offer a Black Friday discount for something like featured placement on a directory, or would that come across as too promotional for the HN community?”

    shdalex · Hacker News · 20 Nov 2025 · open

Against this page

Its headline

Businesses want #1. Let them bid for it.

Buyers say "monetize a directory" and "featured placement", while the headline talks about bidding for #1 and never says directory or money.

Found by our critic in public posts; each quote was checked again at its link.

Is this your launch? LaunchGrill started this grill because its founder asked, and the critic graded it like any other. Claim it and it moves to your account, and your re-grill is open.

Claim this launch
First screen

What a stranger sees first.

fine

Before scrolling, on a laptop and on a phone.

predicted, not measured
The page's first screen on a phone, predicted first looks, brighter means more
Phone 390 × 844 · header 65 px
PartScreenToday
  • The button “See how you get paid”3.4%2.0%
  • Headline8.1%20.8%
  • Subheadline13.8%10.9%
  • Menu bar14.2%22.9%

The button “See how you get paid” gets 2.0% of the first looks on 3.4% of the screen.

After five seconds a stranger would say: “Some $99 kit that lets businesses pay to sit at #1.” They should be able to say: “A $99 kit to launch a pay-to-rank leaderboard on my directory or newsletter.”

Predicted, not measured: a model trained on 1,721 screens people looked at for 3 seconds with eye trackers. On 27 pages it had not seen it ranked the spots people looked at above other spots 83% of the time; “people look at the middle” scores 59%. It can over-weight loud things. UEyes (Jiang et al., CHI 2023, CC BY 4.0) · TranSalNet · 20 Nov

Nothing changed

Same page as 27 Sept, so the same score.

4 fixes · 3 to keep

Four questions, in the order a buyer asks them. Each fix quotes your page and ends in something you can do today.

Fatal · they leave before they understandCostly · they understand and still leaveDrag · it works, and could work better

1. Do I get what it is?

Clarity 1005 of 5 tests pass.
  1. DragClarity · C5 passan afternoon
    “[Get BidKit - $99](/api/checkout)”

    Technical buyers who need to verify the stack or API before paying will bounce.

    Proposalyou decide
    Add a ‘View Docs’ link next to the primary CTA.

2. Is it for me?

Audience 56Nothing to fix here.

What people type

Too fewsearches for “pay-to-rank leaderboard”, the phrase in its title; people type “directory website template” most of the five.

“directory website template” on Google, week by week

Shaded, the last 3 months: −61% on Google · Bing: too few searches to check

Nov 2025Nov 2026
  • “pay-to-rank leaderboard”under 1✓ title
  • “monetize my directory”under 1no
  • “sell featured listings”under 1no
  • “directory website template”24not on it
  • “sponsored spots directory”under 1no

Not every search for “directory website template” is its buyer: the words can mean other things too. Try it in its title or a heading and watch what it brings; keep “pay-to-rank leaderboard” where it already works.

Google Trends: the five phrases in one search, worldwide, the past 12 months, so they share one scale (100 = the busiest week of any of them; shares, not counts). Bing Webmaster Tools: the exact phrase, worldwide, an average week. Read 20 Nov.

Against this page

Its title

BidKit — Pay-to-rank leaderboard software for niche sites (Next.js kit)

Its headline

Businesses want #1. Let them bid for it.

The headline uses none of the five. The title carries “pay-to-rank leaderboard”, but not the one most people type.

3. Do I want it?

Offer 814 of 5 tests pass.
  1. Fix first · 1CostlyOffer · O2 partialminutesup to +5.5
    “No future updates”

    A developer sees a 'no updates' clause on a JS kit and assumes the product is disposable.

    Proposalyou decide
    Offer a limited update window (e.g., 6 months) for the Starter tier.
  2. Fix first · 3DragOffer · O5 passminutes
    “If the untouched kit doesn't run”

    The word 'untouched' signals a loophole, making the guarantee feel like a trap.

    Proposalyou decide
    Remove ‘untouched’ and guarantee the kit’s functionality.

4. Do I believe it?

Proof 1004 of 4 tests pass.
  1. Fix first · 2CostlyProof · P2 passminutes
    “Is this outbid.lol? No... Outbid.lol is one board that made ~$90k in two days.”

    The only verifiable high-value proof is buried in the FAQ, leaving the rest of the page as claims.

    Proposalyou decide
    Place the Outbid.lol $90k result in the ‘Why this exists’ section.
  • Keep: Leave the interactive demo board as the primary visual.
  • Keep: Keep the 'Sponsors pay monthly. Rivalries pay daily' contrast.
  • Keep: Keep the one-time payment model and clear pricing grid.
Why you

Why you, not them.

answered

Products a buyer may meet while looking for what you sell, read the same day, and the free option most of them pick.

Starts atProof from outsideSays what it is
DirstarterBasic, $75 (shown 50% off $150 in a Black Friday banner)“200+ happy customers”, about 11 named maker testimonialsyes
MkdirsLifetime, $59“350+ makers ship faster with Mkdirs”, “100+” directoriesyes

Found by searching your category, read on their own pages the day of this grill. Others a buyer may meet: yourbidlol template, Directorykit, DirectoryStack, Directify.

The option most buyers pick: Selling one sponsor or featured slot a month by hand, with an email and a payment link.

Most directory owners already do this, it costs nothing, and the page itself frames BidKit against it.

What sets you apart, in your page’s words

“A pay-to-rank board sells the same #1 spot over and over — every time a rival refuses to lose it.”
Three visitors

Where each one hesitates.

simulated · not real people

Our critic reads your page as three different strangers would. A simulation from the page alone: not real people, not your analytics.

The directory owner

Runs a niche directory and wants a second income from it.

Hesitates at the plansO2

“No future updates”

If I start on the $49 tier and something breaks with Stripe next year, I am on my own.

Would stay if: A fixed update window for Starter, such as six months, written next to the price (O2).

The skeptic

Has bought a directory boilerplate before and had to rewrite parts of it.

Hesitates at the guaranteeO5

“If the untouched kit doesn't run”

Once I change the theme or the config, this guarantee is gone, so it covers almost nothing.

Would stay if: A guarantee that the kit runs, without the word 'untouched', saying what is covered after setup (O5).

The newcomer

Has a newsletter and has never heard of a pay-to-rank board.

Hesitates at Why this existsP2

“Sponsors pay monthly. Rivalries pay daily.”

It sounds good, but has anyone actually paid real money on a board like this?

Would stay if: The outbid.lol result, 'one board that made ~$90k in two days', moved up into this section instead of the FAQ (P2).

The pattern: All three want to know what they get if things go wrong or whether it works at all, and the answers sit in the small print or the FAQ (O2, O5, P2).

Measured, not scored

What passed, and 6 to tidy.

We click your main button, “See how you get paid”, as a visitor would, then read the page as AI and search do, and measure speed, links, accessibility, privacy and the technical basics. Beside the score, never in it.

  1. DragContrastnot in the score
    Make the faint text darkerShow the fix
    Too faint to read in 1 place (accessibility check).
    Proposalyou decide
    Darken that text (or lighten it on a dark page) until it reaches 4.5 : 1 against its background.
  2. DragAccessibilitynot in the score
    Fix 2 more accessibility problemsShow the fix
    <ul> and <ol> must only directly contain <li>, <script> or <template> elements · <li> elements must be contained in a <ul> or <ol>
    Proposalyou decide
    Fix them in the order listed: each names the element it found.
  3. CostlyPhone speednot in the score

    Unfreeze the page on phones

    Frozen for 0.7 s after it appears; aim for 0.2 s.

    Taps in that time do nothing.

    Proposalyou decide
    Load less JavaScript before the first screen is usable.
  4. DragPrivacynot in the score
    Set cookies only after consentShow the fix
    _ga_09XBZKZFFG, _ga, ph_phc_zpnTb6pUVgMbxhC3zKLEKDfViuzdNKpWo7nesxzQkd7U_posthog

    Worth checking, not a verdict: in the EU most cookies need consent first.

    Proposalyou decide
    Set them only after the visitor agrees.
  5. DragTechnicalnot in the score
    Fix 4 technical settingsShow the fix
    CSP: missing · security.txt: 404 · SPF: missing · DMARC: missing
    Proposalyou decide
    Each is a setting on your host or DNS, named in the line above.
✓ Everything else passed“See how you get paid” goes to the right part of the page, no account asked first · 1,179 words read without JavaScript · a title of 71 characters · a description · a 1354 × 803 preview image · robots.txt lets every AI crawler in · laptop 0.6 s · 592 KB · no layout shift · 9 links work · 7 of 11 technical checksShow all results
Largest paint, desktop
0.6 s
target ≤ 2.5 s
Layout shift
0
target ≤ 0.1
Links on the page
0 broken
9 checked
Accessibility
3 issues
elements must meet minimum color contrast ratio thresholds; <ul> and <ol> must only directly contain <li>, <script> or <template> elements; <li> elements must be contained in a <ul> or <ol>
Frozen on a phone
0.7 s
after it appears; taps do nothing. Target ≤ 0.2 s
Weight on a phone
592 KB
25 requests

The main button: “See how you get paid”

Leads tothe same page (/)

The look

Font families3: __Lato_172376, ui-monospace, Inter
Text sizes11, 9 to 60 px
Filled button styles3
Images far from their shown size1

Search and sharing

Words without JavaScript1179
Title71 characters
Descriptionyes
H1 in the HTML1
Preview image1354 × 803
Site name“bidkit.lol”
Structured data2 blocks
AI crawlers in robots.txtall allowed

Privacy and the law · worth checking, not a verdict

Cookies before any click_ga_09XBZKZFFG, _ga, ph_phc_zpnTb6pUVgMbxhC3zKLEKDfViuzdNKpWo7nesxzQkd7U_posthog
Third parties on loadeasydofollow.dev, i.ytimg.com, launch-nest-ai.base44.app, launchstreak.dev, region1.google-analytics.com, www.easydofollow.dev, www.googletagmanager.com
Imprintno link found
Privacyno link found
Termsno link found

Technical

HTTPS and redirect308 → https://bidkit.lol/
certificatevalid to 2027-02-03 (74 days), Let's Encrypt
HSTSmax-age=63072000; includeSubDomains; preload
CSPmissing
frameDENY
nosniffnosniff
referrerstrict-origin-when-cross-origin
permissionsset
security.txt404
SPFmissing
DMARCmissing
Launch day

Ready for Show HN and Product Hunt?

ready

What those crowds check first, and drafts written from your page's own words. Edit them before you post; we never post for you.

Can I try it without an account?Yes, the demo board on the page takes simulated bids.ready
Who made it?The footer says it is built by Sushant (@sushantkr49).ready
Does the page say what it is?Yes, the first screen says it launches a pay-to-rank leaderboard.ready
Is the price shown?Yes, $99 one-time for Full and $49 for Starter.ready
Drafts for Show HN, Product Hunt and X“Show HN: BidKit – Pay-to-rank leaderboard kit for your directory or newsletter”Show the drafts
Show HN titleShow HN: BidKit – Pay-to-rank leaderboard kit for your directory or newsletter
Product Hunt taglineLet businesses bid for #1 on your directory
First commentHi, I'm Sushant. BidKit is the code to launch a pay-to-rank leaderboard on your directory, newsletter or community: the bidding engine, automatic rankings and Stripe, Dodo or Razorpay payments, $99 once, and you keep 100% of every bid. I built it because [your reason]. [your question]
X postBusinesses want #1. Let them bid for it. BidKit is a Next.js kit to launch a pay-to-rank leaderboard on your directory, newsletter or community. Bidding engine, rankings, payments. $99 one-time. You keep 100% of every bid. bidkit.lol
The score

Your score in detail.

How 87 adds upevery axis and its weight, the level, every test, every grill of this pageShow the sum
Clarity35%
100
+35.0
Audience18%
56
+10.1
Offer29%
81
+23.5
Proof18%
100
+18.0
The sum 86.6, so
87
The top level

Level 4 of 4 Well done

all open: 92
now 87
0406080
4
left to fix
+5
points in reach
92
could reach · Well done
Badges
  • ✓First grill
  • ✓Cooked — reached 60
  • ✓Well done — reached 80
  • Before and after — finish round 2
Every point from a test

The four axes

Every point comes from a test. Open a row, or read the rubric.

Clarity35% of the score
100
C1
Next.js kit
pass
C2
Businesses want #1. Let them bid for it.
pass
C3
Headline is free of jargon
pass
C4
One promise: launch a pay-to-rank leaderboard
pass
C5
Get BidKit - $99
pass
5 passed · 0 partial · 0 failed → 100. Weighted at 35%, this contributes 35.0 of the overall 87.
Audience18% of the score
56
A1
For niche directory, newsletter & community owners
pass
A2
Sponsors pay monthly. Rivalries pay daily.
pass
A3
The problem is not stated until the 'Why this exists' section below the fold
fail
A4
Addressed to directory, newsletter & community owners
pass
3 passed · 0 partial · 1 failed → 56. Weighted at 18%, this contributes 10.1 of the overall 87.
Offer29% of the score
81
O1
Launch price $99
pass
O2
No future updates
partial
O3
One $142 fight for #1 pays back the $99 kit
pass
O4
First 100 licenses
pass
O5
7-day working-code guarantee
pass
4 passed · 1 partial · 0 failed → 81. Weighted at 29%, this contributes 23.5 of the overall 87.
Proof18% of the score
100
P1
Interactive AI Tools Board demo
pass
P2
Outbid.lol made ~$90k in two days
pass
P3
Interactive board on the page
pass
P4
Built by me, used by twelve people
pass
4 passed · 0 partial · 0 failed → 100. Weighted at 18%, this contributes 18.0 of the overall 87.
35.0 + 10.1 + 23.5 + 18.0 = 86.6 → 87.
Full page read.
2 grills

Every grill of this page

  1. 87Well done27 Sept 2026
  2. 87Well done20 Nov 2026You are here

Your launch, read the same way.

Free. No card.

Ready to launch? The Launch Kit: your agent submits you to up to 85 free directories · $49 →