P4 · Honest for the stage
One of the 18 tests every grill uses. Proof is 18% of the score.
Is the proof proportionate — a pre-launch page claiming "trusted by thousands" fails harder than one that says "built by me, used by twelve people, here they are"?
It is scored pass, partial or fail, and it can be marked as not applying. Every finding filed under it quotes the page. The whole checklist is on one page.
What does “honest for the stage” ask, and how do you pass it?
What it means. The proof is proportionate to where the product is. The rubric's example: a pre-launch page claiming "trusted by thousands" fails harder than one that says "built by me, used by twelve people, here they are".
Why it costs you. A visitor can usually tell when a page claims more than a new product could have, and once one claim looks inflated, the rest of the page stops being believed. The rubric's strongest Proof anchor claims nothing the stage cannot support.
How to pass. Claim only what is true today, and make the small numbers concrete: the few real users, named; the work you have done, shown; the date you started. Early, honest proof reads as confidence. If a line on your page would embarrass you were a visitor to ask for the evidence, take it out before launch.
How real pages did
Of the 60 public launches judged on it, as of 18 Nov 2026: 53 passed, 3 partly passed, 4 failed. That is a small sample, from the record, not a survey.
Of the 60 public launches judged on it, as of 18 Nov 2026: 53 passed, 3 partly passed, 4 failed. That is a small sample, from the record, not a survey.
Pages that missed it
5 of 7
Kling 4.0 AI Video Generator20 Oct 202651UndercookedKling 4.0 AI Video Generatorfailed“Kling 4.0 is coming soon.”
A visitor who reads the footer realizes the entire sales page is for a non-existent product and leaves.
51Undercooked20 Oct 2026
Explore the Solana ecosystem16 Oct 202618RawExplore the Solana ecosystempartly passed“the best" in "Find the best companies, protocols, and apps”
A sceptical crypto reader discounts "best" with no stated method, and trusts the rest of the page less.
18Raw16 Oct 2026
ReelAI6 Nov 202633RawReelAIfailed"#1" claim without supporting data
33Raw6 Nov 2026
Free AI Photo Enhancer Online2 Nov 202655UndercookedFree AI Photo Enhancer OnlinefailedCopy: "Third-party retention periods, training use and processing regions have not been verified. We cannot promise immediate deletion or that images are never used for training. Avoid uploading sensitive photos if you need these guarantees."
55Undercooked2 Nov 2026
Make your bucket list real.26 Oct 202636RawMake your bucket list real.partly passedno overclaims, but no evidence of scale
36Raw26 Oct 2026
Pages that passed
3 of 53
AI Humanizer18 Nov 202663CookedAI HumanizerpassedClaims are modest and avoid 'trusted by thousands' language
63Cooked18 Nov 2026
gaash.ai12 Nov 202673Cookedgaash.aipassedCites SparkToro, Ahrefs, and OpenAI.
73Cooked12 Nov 2026- PDFLalssi11 Nov 202665CookedPDFLalssipassed
No exaggerated claims about user counts or trust.
65Cooked11 Nov 2026
See whether your page passes Honest for the stage.
Free. No card.