P4 · Honest for the stage
One of the 18 tests every grill uses. Proof is 18% of the score.
The test, as the critic reads it
Is the proof proportionate — a pre-launch page claiming "trusted by thousands" fails harder than one that says "built by me, used by twelve people, here they are"?
It is scored pass, partial or fail, and it can be marked as not applying. Every finding filed under it quotes the page. The whole checklist is on one page.
How real pages did
Of the 23 public launches judged on it, as of 1 Oct 2026: 21 passed, 0 partly passed, 2 failed. That is a small sample, from the record, not a survey.
Pages that missed it
- Fenlofailed · 17 Raw · 8 Sept 2026
"Used by professionals at" followed by logos of the tools the product integrates with
- LaunchGrillfailed · 84 Well done · 7 Sept 2026
Text says '2 launches graded so far' and 'See all 2', but the UI displays 3 cards
Pages that passed
- Flouiepassed · 59 Undercooked · 1 Oct 2026
Founding Plan positioning is honest for the stage
- plume.koumastudio.compassed · 66 Cooked · 1 Oct 2026
No exaggerated claims like "trusted by millions".
- Nektarpassed · 68 Cooked · 1 Oct 2026
28 ratings is a proportionate and honest claim for the current stage