Skip to content
Proof · 18% of the score

P2 · Specific

One of the 18 tests every grill uses. Proof is 18% of the score.

The test, as the critic reads it
Is the proof specific (names, numbers, dates) rather than decorative (logos of tools used, star ratings without a source, "loved by makers")?

It is scored pass, partial or fail, and it can be marked as not applying. Every finding filed under it quotes the page. The whole checklist is on one page.

How to pass

What does “specific” ask, and how do you pass it?

What it means. The proof is specific, with names, numbers and dates, rather than decorative. The rubric's examples of decorative are logos of the tools you use, star ratings without a source, and "loved by makers".

Why it costs you. Decorative proof looks like proof from a distance and like padding up close. The rubric's weakest Proof anchor is exactly this: "as seen on" logos that are really tech-stack logos, and testimonials with first names and no faces or links.

How to pass. Replace each vague signal with a checkable one: a full name with a role and a link, a number with what it counts and when, a quote that says what changed for that person. Remove the logos of tools you build with; they prove nothing about the product. One specific proof does more than a row of general ones.

The record

How real pages did

Of the 60 public launches judged on it, as of 18 Nov 2026: 26 passed, 11 partly passed, 23 failed. That is a small sample, from the record, not a survey.

60
judged
26
passed
11
partly
23
failed

Of the 60 public launches judged on it, as of 18 Nov 2026: 26 passed, 11 partly passed, 23 failed. That is a small sample, from the record, not a survey.

Pages that missed it

Pages that passed

See whether your page passes Specific.

Free. No card.