Skip to content
Grill · 20 Nov · Round 2 of 5

Edit Mind landing page review

76
Cooked

Higher than 54 of the 63 other launches on the public record, level with 2 (86%)

“The page sells a powerful tool but fails to name the target audience until the very bottom.” 

What we read, 20 Nov at 20:40: the page, its pricing page, at laptop and phone width.

Fix this first

Add “For video editors” to the start of the sub-headline

Fatal · minutes · up to +5.6. From your page’s line “The entire first viewport” (copy test A1).

Then

  1. 2Move "Stop digging+5.6
  2. 3Remove the company logos entirely+4.1
Fix 1, 2 and 3:7693Well done

The numbers

This page, in numbers.

Its four scores against the public record, and its public grills over time.

Its four axes

edit-mind.comthe median launch on the public record
81
median 81
100
median 64
77
median 77
25
median 39
Audience252 of 4 tests pass

It talks to anyone with lots of footage, never names video editors as the reader, and keeps its pain line for the bottom.

  • missed:A1Named
  • passed:A2Their words
  • missed:A3Pain before product
  • passed:A4The payer

A1, missed: No mention of ‘video editors’ or ‘filmmakers’ in the copy.

Choose an axis to read it.

Where 76 sits

54 of 63other launches score lower

0s10s20s30s40s50s60s70s80s90smedian 66

The public record, 22 Nov: each launch counted once, by its latest public grill.

Its public grills

2 publicsince 14 Sept. This one, 76, is the best.

050100727614 Sept20 Novv0.13v0.14

Under the dates, the rubric each was graded on; today’s is v0.14. Hollow dots: an older rubric, so not comparable one to one. Private grills are left out: only the owner sees them.

First screen

What a stranger sees first.

2 problems

Before scrolling, on a laptop and on a phone.

predicted, not measured
The page's first screen on a phone, predicted first looks, brighter means more
Phone 390 × 844 · header 57 px
PartScreenTodayFixed
  • The button “Sound off”1.0%0.1%2.8%
  • Headline8.9%24.4%25.0%
  • Subheadline7.9%14.3%14.6%
  • The largest card20.7%10.5%9.1%
  • Menu bar6.8%9.8%9.2%

The button “Sound off” gets 0.1% of the first looks on 1.0% of the screen, though it is the one thing a visitor must use; eyes go to the headline. With the fixes it gets 2.8%, about 28 times more.

After five seconds a stranger would say: “Some app for searching video clips, I think for Mac. Not sure who it's for.” They should be able to say: “A Mac app that finds moments in your footage and sends them to your editor.”

Predicted, not measured: a model trained on 1,721 screens people looked at for 3 seconds with eye trackers. On 27 pages it had not seen it ranked the spots people looked at above other spots 83% of the time; “people look at the middle” scores 59%. It can over-weight loud things. The fixes are drawn by us on a copy of your page in our browser; your page is not touched. UEyes (Jiang et al., CHI 2023, CC BY 4.0) · TranSalNet · 20 Nov

The headline names no product: see it in Your message.

Your message

Your message, as a buyer reads it.

4 fixes · 2 to keep

Four questions, in the order a buyer asks them. Each fix quotes your page and ends in something you can do today.

Fatal · they leave before they understandCostly · they understand and still leaveDrag · it works, and could work better

1. Do I get what it is?

Clarity 814 of 5 tests pass.
  1. DragClarity · C1 partialminutesup to +6.7
    “Find the moment. Not the file.”

    The headline is a slogan; a stranger must read the sub-headline to realize it is a software tool.

    Proposalyou decide
    Add a category label like “AI Video Search” above the headline.

2. Is it for me?

Audience 252 of 4 tests pass.
  1. Fix first · 1FatalAudience · A1 failminutesup to +5.6
    “The entire first viewport”

    A visitor who isn't a video editor doesn't know this isn't for them and bounces.

    Proposalyou decide
    Add “For video editors” to the start of the sub-headline.
  2. Fix first · 2CostlyAudience · A3 failminutesup to +5.6
    “Stop digging. Start finding.”

    The strongest emotional hook is buried at the bottom, missing the chance to frame the solution.

    Proposalyou decide
    Move “Stop digging. Start finding.” to the top as a pre-headline.

What people type

Too fewsearches for “search years of footage”, the phrase on its page; people type “ai video search” most of the five.

“ai video search” on Google, week by week

Shaded, the last 3 months: −70% on Google · Bing: too few searches to check

Nov 2025Nov 2026
  • “search years of footage”under 1✓ on the page
  • “ai video search”53not on it
  • “find clips in footage”under 1no
  • “search video by transcript”under 1no
  • “video footage organizer”under 1no

Not every search for “ai video search” is its buyer: the words can mean other things too. Try it in its title or a heading and watch what it brings; keep “search years of footage” where it already works.

Google Trends: the five phrases in one search, worldwide, the past 12 months, so they share one scale (100 = the busiest week of any of them; shares, not counts). Bing Webmaster Tools: the exact phrase, worldwide, an average week. Read 20 Nov.

Against this page

Its title

Orcah Studio — Find the moment. Not the file.

Its headline

Find the moment.

The headline uses none of the five. The title uses none of them either.

3. Do I want it?

Offer 100Nothing to fix here.

4. Do I believe it?

Proof 773 of 4 tests pass.
  1. Fix first · 3CostlyProof · P2 partialminutesup to +4.1
    “employers from stargazers' LinkedIn, not endorsements”

    The logo wall feels like a trick, eroding trust in the product's actual adoption.

    Proposalsyou decide which, if any
    ARemove the company logos entirely.
    BReplace logos with three specific, named testimonials from professional editors.
  • Keep: The 'Buy for Mac' button in the first viewport includes the price and discount immediately.
  • Keep: The hardware requirements (M1, 16GB RAM) are stated explicitly and repeated in the FAQ.
Why you

Why you, not them.

not answered

Products a buyer may meet while looking for what you sell, read the same day, and the free option most of them pick.

Starts atProof from outsideSays what it is
Jumpernot shown (a “Lifetime” per-seat license, “Buy once”, no amount on the pricing page)Customer logos under “Accelerating media production worldwide”; “Jumper allows me to move 10 times faster than I used to.” (Nathan Furst)partly
Clipto$12.49 /month, billed yearly (monthly plan shows a $9.99 first month)Logo block “Trusted by professionals at leading companies and universities”; “I just search for the moment I need and it’s there in seconds.” (Daniel, Filmmaker)no

Found by searching your category, read on their own pages the day of this grill. Others a buyer may meet: DAAAM, SceneSearch, Focus Video Search, Twelve Labs.

The option most buyers pick: Scrubbing through clips by hand, or using the search already built into Final Cut Pro or Premiere Pro.

Editors already own these tools. Final Cut Pro already transcribes speech, so $199 has to beat ‘good enough’ at no cost.

  1. CostlyWhy younot in the score

    Say why this beats other footage search tools

    The only comparison on the page is with its own Docker version. “Your footage stays on your Mac.” sits mid-page with no contrast to other tools.

    A buyer comparing Jumper or Clipto needs to see in one line what this app does differently, and the page never sets them side by side.

    Proposalyou decide
    Indexing runs locally. Nothing is uploaded. $199 once. No subscription. Sends the shot to Final Cut Pro, DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro.
Three visitors

Where each one hesitates.

simulated · not real people

Our critic reads your page as three different strangers would. A simulation from the page alone: not real people, not your analytics.

Video editor

Cuts in Final Cut Pro or Premiere Pro and has drives full of old projects.

Hesitates at the headline and the line under itA1

“Search years of footage by what someone said, who was there, or what the shot looked like.”

Is this a pro editing tool, or something for people sorting their phone videos?

Would stay if: Say it is for video editors in the first line under the headline (A1), and put "Sends clips to Final Cut Pro, DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro" near the top.

Skeptic who tried Jumper

Has already paid for an AI footage search tool and knows the claims.

Hesitates at the company logosP2

“employers from stargazers' LinkedIn, not endorsements”

So none of these companies use the app. Why are their logos here?

Would stay if: Take the logos off and lead with the named r/selfhosted quotes and the 1,848 GitHub stars instead (P2).

Newcomer to footage search

Makes family or travel videos and has never heard of this kind of tool.

Hesitates at the headlineC1

“Find the moment. Not the file.”

Nice line, but what is it: an app, a website, a plugin?

Would stay if: A plain label above the headline that names the product type, like "AI Video Search" (C1).

The pattern: All three stop near the top: the first screen says neither who it is for nor what kind of product it is (A1, C1), and the first proof they see is only borrowed (P2).

Measured, not scored

What passed, and 8 to tidy.

We click your main button, “Buy for Mac Regular price $249$199”, as a visitor would, then read the page as AI and search do, and measure speed, links, accessibility, privacy and the technical basics. Beside the score, never in it.

  1. CostlyAfter the clicknot in the score

    Show a result before asking for an account

    Opens /checkout/polar_c_mayWXBQEkdHwZ1rXJZKv4nlVNBcgavslRlWYC3F9q61: 4 fields (email, text, select-one, checkbox); asks for a card

    Nothing comes back before the visitor has an account. Every step before the first result loses people.

    Proposalyou decide
    Let the visitor see one result before the account, or say on the button what comes next.
  2. DragContrastnot in the score
    Make the faint text darkerShow the fix
    Too faint to read in 18 places (accessibility check).
    Proposalyou decide
    Darken that text (or lighten it on a dark page) until it reaches 4.5 : 1 against its background.
  3. DragAccessibilitynot in the score
    Fix 1 more accessibility problemShow the fix
    Heading levels should only increase by one
    Proposalyou decide
    Fix them in the order listed: each names the element it found.
  4. DragImagesnot in the score
    Shrink an oversized imageShow the fix
    The file is 512 × 512 px, shown at 24 × 24: 21× more than needed.
    Proposalyou decide
    Export it at 48 px wide (twice its shown size).
  5. CostlyPhone speednot in the score

    Unfreeze the page on phones

    Frozen for 1.4 s after it appears; aim for 0.2 s.

    Taps in that time do nothing.

    Proposalyou decide
    Load less JavaScript before the first screen is usable.
  6. DragPrivacynot in the score
    Set cookies only after consentShow the fix
    __cf_bm

    Worth checking, not a verdict: in the EU most cookies need consent first.

    Proposalyou decide
    Set them only after the visitor agrees.
  7. DragTechnicalnot in the score
    Fix 9 technical settingsShow the fix
    HTTPS and redirect: 200 → no redirect · HSTS: missing · CSP: missing · frame: missing · nosniff: missing · referrer: missing · permissions: missing · security.txt: 404 · DMARC: p=none
    Proposalyou decide
    Each is a setting on your host or DNS, named in the line above.
✓ Everything else passed1,387 words read without JavaScript · a title of 45 characters · a description · a 1200 × 630 preview image · robots.txt lets every AI crawler in · laptop 0.4 s · 1,444 KB · no layout shift · 23 links work · terms, privacy all there · 2 of 11 technical checksShow all results
Largest paint, desktop
0.4 s
target ≤ 2.5 s
Layout shift
0.07
target ≤ 0.1
Links on the page
0 broken
23 checked; 3 could not be checked
Accessibility
2 issues
elements must meet minimum color contrast ratio thresholds; heading levels should only increase by one
Frozen on a phone
1.4 s
after it appears; taps do nothing. Target ≤ 0.2 s
Weight on a phone
1,444 KB
61 requests

The main button: “Buy for Mac Regular price $249$199”

Leads toanother site (polar.sh)
Fields4: email, text, select-one, checkbox
A passwordno
Email to confirmno
A cardyes

The look

Font families5: Figtree, Geist, Geist Mono, EB Garamond, Inter
Text sizes18, 12 to 72 px
Filled button styles3
Images far from their shown size12

Search and sharing

Words without JavaScript1387
Title45 characters
Descriptionyes
H1 in the HTML1
Preview image1200 × 630
Site namemissing
Structured data3 blocks
AI crawlers in robots.txtall allowed

Privacy and the law · worth checking, not a verdict

Cookies before any click__cf_bm
Third parties on loadapi.github.com, app.cal.com, fonts.googleapis.com, fonts.gstatic.com
Imprintno link found
Privacy/privacy · 200
Terms/terms-and-conditions · 200

Technical

HTTPS and redirect200 → no redirect
certificatevalid to 2027-02-01 (73 days), Google Trust Services
HSTSmissing
CSPmissing
framemissing
nosniffmissing
referrermissing
permissionsmissing
security.txt404
SPFv=spf1 include:_spf.mx.cloudflare.net include:zohomail.com ~all
DMARCp=none
Launch day

Ready for Show HN and Product Hunt?

2 to fix first

What those crowds check first, and drafts written from your page's own words. Edit them before you post; we never post for you.

Can I try it without an account?No free trial of the Mac app; the only paths are buying for $199 with a 30-day refund or self-hosting the open-source Docker version from GitHub.fix first
Who made it?Yes: “Ilias Haddad, founder”, with a photo and a quote.ready
Does the page say what it is?Only by hint: “Search years of footage” and “Buy for Mac” suggest a Mac app, but nothing names the type.fix first
Is the price shown?Yes: $199 once (regular $249), and $149 to pre-order on Linux or Windows.ready
Drafts for Show HN, Product Hunt and X“Show HN: Orcah Studio – Search your footage by what was said or shown”Show the drafts
Show HN titleShow HN: Orcah Studio – Search your footage by what was said or shown
Product Hunt taglineFind any moment in years of footage, on your Mac
First commentHi, I'm Ilias, and I built Orcah Studio because [your reason]. It indexes your footage on your Mac, then lets you search by what someone said, who was there or what the shot looked like, and sends the clip to Final Cut Pro, DaVinci Resolve or Premiere Pro. Nothing is uploaded, it is $199 once with a 30-day refund, and the open-source Docker version keeps going. [your question]
X postOrcah Studio searches years of footage by what someone said, who was there, or what the shot looked like. Indexing runs on your Mac, nothing is uploaded. Sends clips to Final Cut Pro, DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro. $199 once, 30-day refund.
The score

Your score in detail.

How 76 adds upevery axis and its weight, the level, every test, every grill of this pageShow the sum
Clarity35%
81
+28.4
Audience18%
25
+4.5
Offer29%
100
+29.0
Proof18%
77
+13.9
The sum 75.7, so
76
4 points to Well done

Level 3 of 4 Cooked

all open: 100
now 76
0406080
4
left to fix
+24
points in reach
100
could reach · Well done
Badges
  • ✓First grill
  • ✓Cooked — reached 60
  • Well done — no round left on this launch
  • ✓Before and after — finish round 2
Every point from a test

The four axes

Every point comes from a test. Open a row, or read the rubric.

Clarity35% of the score
81
C1
"Find the moment. Not the file."
partial
C2
"Find the moment. Not the file."
pass
C3
Headline is free of adjectives like 'seamless' or 'AI-driven'.
pass
C4
First viewport focuses solely on searching footage.
pass
C5
"Buy for Mac" button in the first viewport.
pass
4 passed · 1 partial · 0 failed → 81. Weighted at 35%, this contributes 28.4 of the overall 76.
Audience18% of the score
25
A1
No mention of 'video editors' or 'filmmakers' in the copy.
fail
A2
"footage", "shot", "clip"
pass
A3
"Stop digging. Start finding." appears only at the bottom of the page.
fail
A4
Addressed to the person searching and managing the footage.
pass
2 passed · 0 partial · 2 failed → 25. Weighted at 18%, this contributes 4.5 of the overall 76.
Offer29% of the score
100
O1
"$199" visible in the first viewport button.
pass
O2
Clear distinction between Mac purchase and Win/Linux pre-order.
pass
O3
$199 lifetime license for professional utility.
pass
O4
"Black Friday price, ends Sun, Nov 30"
pass
O5
"30-day refund, no questions asked."
pass
5 passed · 0 partial · 0 failed → 100. Weighted at 29%, this contributes 29.0 of the overall 76.
Proof18% of the score
77
P1
"1,848 stars" on GitHub.
pass
P2
"employers from stargazers' LinkedIn, not endorsements"
partial
P3
Screenshots of search interface and results.
pass
P4
Honest distinction between Docker version and Desktop app.
pass
3 passed · 1 partial · 0 failed → 77. Weighted at 18%, this contributes 13.9 of the overall 76.
28.4 + 4.5 + 29.0 + 13.9 = 75.7 → 76.
Full page read.
2 grills

Every grill of this page

  1. 72Cooked14 Sept 2026
  2. 76Cooked20 Nov 2026+4You are here

Your launch, read the same way.

Free. No card.

Ready to launch? The Launch Kit: your agent submits you to up to 85 free directories · $49 →